Amy is a major antagonist of Total Drama fanfic Total Drama Pahkitew Island Reordered. She is the cruel twin sister and archenemy of Sammy who joins Total Drama along with her. However, it is quickly revealed that she has a truly evil personality in utter contrast to her sister. Known to have mistreated Sammy for years in the past, Amy is shown to be a cruel, homicidal, stuck-up, mean-spirited and abusive sister towards Sammy, as well as even frequently trying to take credit for ideas came up with by Samey.
History[]
Amy, along with the rest of the new cast, was first seen on the zeppelin, with the rest of the new cast, being disgusted by Beardo's beat boxing. She quickly makes Sammy switch seats with her, until she sees the "giant," Jasmine, and makes Sammy switch back. When Chris forces the cast to jump out, she sees that Sammy was unlucky enough to get a bag without a parachute. Amy mockingly says that she's not gonna miss her sister, only to find out that, to her horror, her bag is without a parachute too, making her land in the water.
Amy, along with the rest of the contestants without parachutes, was placed on team Pimâpotew Kinosewak. During the challenge, she was assigned to help Sammy and Rodney put wood in the wheel barrel, however she and Sammy weren't that helpful, as Amy just used Sammy as a human shield to protect from Chef's tennis balls.
Before the next challenge, Amy offers Jasmine her help with foraging for food, but rather than going herself, she pushes Sammy out of the treehouse. Amy demands that she get her food and not be as lazy as she was at birth. Amy later takes credit for having gathered the blueberries, pointing out that she sent Sammy in the first place. She willingly teams up with her sister for the first leg of the obstacle course, but refused to help Sammy pushing their pig on the logs. Eventually, annoyed with the fact that she "has to do everything here", Amy helps her twin sister push the pig, but once that happens, they fall down in the ditch.
Before the third challenge, Amy tries to take credit for her sister's helping Jasmine with foraging for food, only for the latter to reveal that Sammy was the one who helped her. During the challenge, Amy uses Rodney as a human shield to save herself from being attacked by Sky. Later, the sisters ambush her, with Sammy successfully hitting Sky, eliminating her from the challenge. Amy tries to take the credit for herself, but Jasmine stops her. The trio then tries to take out Shawn, but Amy tries to take the balloon away and do it by herself, arguing with her teammates, which informs Shawn about their whereabouts and allows him to eliminate them. Sammy, Jasmine, Rodney and Topher vote for Amy, leading to her elimination.
Three challenges later, she returns to the island, covered in seaweed, algae and barnacles. Chef Hatchet caught her and brought to the remaining contestants, allowing Sammy to rub the fact that their team won the challenge without her in Amy's face, after which she was fired away from the Cannon of Shame, much to her sister's delight.
Amy makes another attempt to return to the island in order to get her revenge on Sammy. During this, she encountered the nude bomb which blew off all of her clothes. To cover her nudity, Chris and Chef dressed her in a leftover bib and diaper from the previous challenge, making Sammy laugh at her and claim her revenge for tricking her into dressing up as a baby as a Halloween prank. After this, Chris fires the humiliated cheerleader away from the Cannon of Shame for the third time.
After the semi-final challenge, Chef Hatchet brought Amy to the island specifically to be launched away with Scarlett simply for the sake of continuing the gag of her getting launched from the Cannon of Shame every three episodes. Before being fired away, she tells Dave to beat Sammy in the final challenge and that he has her support, much to his dismay.
Before the final challenge, Amy was brought along all of the other eliminated contestants, where she chooses to root for Dave. When finalists were forced to choose their helpers, Sammy got Amy, but rejected her, refusing to trust her.
For the final part of the challenge, Chris tells all rejected helpers, including Amy, to follow him and gives them controllers that would allow them to throw obstacles at Sammy and Dave to slow them down and if neither of the finalists will get to the finish line in ten minutes, Amy, Max, Sugar and Leonard will share the million dollar prize. When Leonard asks Sugar and Amy about their plans on their parts of prize money, the latter reveals that she wants to burn it in front of Sammy, much to LARPer's concern. Despite their attempts, one of the finalists manages to cross the finish line before the time runs out.
In canon ending, Amy screams in disappointment that her sister won the million dollar prize. After that, she tries to reconcile with Sammy, trying to to justify all her past actions towards her with numerous excuses such as tough love. Sammy then tells her that she'll only accept her apology and share some of her prize money with her if she records a video of her apologizing and posts it to YouTube, to which Amy furiously refuses. When the contestants, previous seasons' winners and Chef Hatchet leave the island, Topher notices that they miss someone, to which Sammy reveals that Amy said she'd get a ride home with someone else. Meanwhile, Amy admits that "at least things can only get better from here", only for rain to suddenly start, making her sigh in defeat and wonder what she's done to deserve this.
In alternative ending, Amy returns with other rejected helpers, annoyed that she failed to get the part of million dollar prize. Later, she, along the other contestants (minus Sugar), previous seasons' winners and Chef Hatchet, leaves the island.