This villain was proposed and approved on the Inconsistently Heinous Wiki for being a villain who, despite their strong heinousness, have numerous disqualifications preventing them from being PE or NPE.
Only villains who have been approved on that wiki can be in the Inconsistently Heinous Category and have this template. Those who haven't been proposed/approved cannot since it hasn't been determined if they apply or not. Any act of removing this villain from the category without a Removal Proposal shall be considered vandalism (or a futile "heroic" attempt of redemption) and the user will have high chances of being terminated blocked. You cannot make said Removal Proposal without permission from an admin first. Additional Notice: This template is meant for admin maintenance only. Users who misuse the template will be blocked for a week minimum.
This article's content is marked as Mature Needlemouse found something very brutal for those with a weak heart. The page Duncan (Total Drama YTP: Duncan Murders Chris) contains mature content that may include coarse language, sexual references, and/or graphic images which may be disturbing to some. Mature pages are recommended for those who are 18 years of age and older. If you're 18 years or older or are comfortable with graphic material, you are free to view this page. Otherwise, you should close this page and view another page.
“
If anyone thinks I've gone soft or lost my mojo, then let's say I found a way to set the record straight.
„
~ Duncan, having snapped and deciding to kill Chris, which sets off the plot of the video.
This version of Duncan is the titular villainous protagonist of the Total Drama fan video Total Drama YTP: Duncan Murders Chris. In this video, Duncan finally snaps from the abuse that Chris and the others put him through to the point of going on a killing spree.
The video starts with Duncan sleeping in bed and listening to his music until he's waken up by a horn. He complains about never getting to sleep until he sees a gas grenade and is knocked out by it.
On the island, Chris has Duncan tied up and with a mental patient mask. Duncan angrily tells Chris to "Eat D**k" but Chris tells him that's Duncan's job. Chris then has Chef sexually abuse Duncan by forcing him to literally "eat d**k", much to Duncan's agony. Fortunately, the scene is censored but Chris reveals Duncan confessing to his sad story about his dog Petey running away from him when he was six and another video shows him crying about what happened to him. Instead of feeling sympathy for him, the cast members cruelly laugh at him. A hurt and traumatized Duncan tells them it's not funny but Chris evily laughs and taunts Duncan about not being so tough. He then further insults Duncan by planning to bring him back for the next All Stars Season which will be "C**k vs. Bigger C**k".
Angered and finally snapped from the abuse he just suffered, Duncan vows to show them who's gone soft, he'll show them all.
Duncan then shows up with an axe as Chris angrily claims that he can't kill the host but a smirking Duncan doesn't care and tells him to feel the pain. A confessional of him reveals if anyone thinks he's gone soft, then he found a way to set the record straight. Duncan then angrily strikes a screaming Chris with the axe, killing him as blood splatters on the horrified contestants. Noah then reveals they knew this moment would come but they didn't know when while now realizing why his little cousins aren't allowed to watch the show. A horrified Beth claims that Chris is dead but a confused Lindsay asks if he's dead dead. A blood covered Duncan confirms it without remorse for what he did. Tyler successfully impresses Lindsay by claiming that he can do that too as they ignore Chris' body. DJ, Owen, and Chef laugh at what Duncan did but Courtney is not impressed and questions what is it about this gory stuff that guys love.
Everyone cheers this on due to the abuse they suffered from Chris and start partying over it since that means no challenges and no alliances. Duncan can be seen failing to impress Courtney with his dance moves while also cheering when Owen announced a party next week.
In the morning, Duncan's back hurts because Harold put rocks in the mattress. An angry Duncan decides that it's time for Harold to die. He then threatens Harold but his back pain prevents from planning to beat him to a pulp. Harold cheers at this but Duncan recovers and murders the screaming Harold (off-camera) with a hook as Tyler watches in horror.
In the confessional, Duncan reveals that he knows about Tyler witnessing what happened and warns us that Tyler better know better while Tyler admits to being bad with secrets.
Under the dock, Tyler tries to warn Lindsay about what happened but Duncan finds them and angrily murders Tyler by dropping a canoe on him. Lindsay screams in horror and runs away as a laughing Duncan chases her but trips and sprains his ankle. As he holds his ankle in pain, Courtney gets worried and Duncan asks her to help him but Alejandro seduces her and she gives in, making Duncan angry and jealous. Noah then taunts Duncan about his girlfriend turning on him and calls him a loser but Duncan angrily snaps and drowns Noah as Owen looks on in despair and horror. In the confessional, Owen agrees that Noah's aunty should block the show because it's way out of control. Owen then mourns Noah's death but is also worried that he might be next.
True to his words, Owen is pushed down a cliff by Duncan and lands on numerous objects until Duncan pulls out a dynamite detonator and activates, blowing Owen up.
Due to his actions, everyone's scared of him now and he decides to kill them all to satisfy his own bloodlust. He then stalks Geoff and DJ as DJ is taking a leak in the bathroom and begs Geoff not to leave him when he's taking a leak which Geoff promised. However, DJ encounters Duncan and screams in horror as he gets murdered with a hook. Geoff hears the noise but also finds Duncan and screams in horror too before being murdered as well. Duncan puts an x on them on his list.
Throughout a montage, he kills Alejandro by dragging him up to the ceiling via pulling his hair, kills a scared Courtney for turning on him, is shown crossing out Leshawna and Izzy, killing Heather in the shower, killing Lindsay with a chainsaw, poisoning Trent, pushing Justin off a ledge, throwing a dingo at Cody, distracting Chef with an arrow before throwing a knife at the guy's groin for sexually abusing him earlier, and then burns the list, meaning he successfully killed the rest. He confirms this by sadistically saying "and then there was one", referring to himself. He then goes to bed and asks the guys if he's right but then remembered he killed everyone and looks annoyed that no one is left to laugh at his excellent jokes. However, he is happy by what he's done and shows no remorse for it. He is now relieved to live in peace and get a chance to take the prize money. However, he's arrested (off-screen), possibly due to the audience deciding to call 911.
In prison, he writes a letter to his mom and wonders how she is as he talks about his arrest for killing his hosts and castmates but then surprisingly breaks out of prison quickly and is last seen telling us that it's been nice chatting with us but he's really got to run from the law as he successfully escapes. His whereabouts are unknown but he's now most likely a fugitive and everyone will be on the lookout for him. The video then turns to the end credits after he runs away.
Personality[]
In his first appearance, he is like his canon self but after being abused and tormented by Chris, Chef, and the cast members, he finally snaps and becomes a vengeful, bloodthirsty, psychotic, and sociopathic murderer who kills anyone that either angers him or tries to tell on him. He also shows no remorse for killing them.
Despite this, he did care for those who didn't mistreat him and he probably would've spared them if they hadn't messed with him or cruelly laughed at him. He also seems to like talking to the audience and doesn't plan to harm them, even if they probably called the police on him. He also still loved his mother and still wrote to her.
Victims[]
1: Chris McLean: Struck in the chest with an axe for abusing Duncan, having Chef rape him, and making fun of him.
2: Harold: Gutted with a hook for putting rocks in his mattress and mocking him.
3: Tyler: Crushed to death with a canoe for trying to rat him out.
4: Noah: Drowned to death for mocking him about Courtney's cheating.
5: Owen: Pushed down a cliff and blown up out of blood lust.
6: DJ: Gutted with a hook (off-screen).
7: Geoff: Gutted with a hook (off-screen).
8: Alejandro: Grabbed by the hair and pulled up into an unknown death for seducing Courtney.
9: Courtney: Killed with a knife (off-camera) for cheating on him.
10: Izzy: Unknown but seen being crossed off of Duncan's list.
11: Leshawna: Same as Izzy.
12: Heather: Killed in the shower (off-screen).
13: Lindsay: Killed with a chainsaw (off-screen).
14: Trent: Poisoned.
15: Justin: Pushed off a movie set with a wooden sword.
16: Cody: Mauled by a dingo thrown at him and falls to his death.
17: Chef Hatchet: Groin stabbed with a thrown knife for raping Duncan.
18-51: The rest of the cast and hosts: Unknown but deaths confirmed when Duncan burns the list and said there was one. (It's possible that the second and third generation contestants were killed as well along with Sierra and Blaineley)
Quotes[]
“
Man, I'm never gonna get some sleep. (Then a gas grenade enters the room.) What the?
„
~ Duncan, before he gets knocked out.
“
Eat D**k, McLean!
„
~ Duncan, showing hostility towards Chris for kidnapping him.
“
My dog Petey ran away on me when I was six.
„
~ Duncan, expressing what happened to his dog during his childhood.
“
It's not funny, man.
„
~ Duncan, hurt and heartbroken by how everyone is making fun of him for getting sexually abused.
“
Everyone thinks I've gone soft and lost my edge. I'll show them who's gone soft, I'll show them all!
„
~ Duncan, vowing revenge for his abuse and mistreatment.
“
Here comes the pain.
„
~ Duncan, about to kill Chris.
“
Yep, totally dead.
„
~ Duncan, confirming Chris' death and not showing remorse.
“
Oh my back. What's with the mattresses? Are they filled with rocks or something?
„
~ Duncan, receiving back pains from sleeping on a mattress filled with rocks.
“
It's defiantly time for Harold to die.
„
~ Duncan, planning to kill Harold for putting rocks in his mattress.
“
Give me a good reason not to beat you to a pulp- AGH!
„
~ Duncan, threating Harold before stopping due to his back pain.
“
Tyler saw me kill Harold and now he's all freaked out but I think he knows better than to talk about it. He better know better!
„
~ Duncan, threatening to kill Tyler if he tattletales.
“
Tyler, dead.
„
~ Duncan, dropping a canoe on Tyler for snitching on him.
“
Ow, my ankle. I think I sprained it. (Courtney: (worried) "Duncan, are you okay?") Help me.
„
~ Duncan, spraining his ankle from chasing Lindsay and begging Courtney to help him before getting betrayed by her.
“
Enough of a man to take your head off!
„
~ Duncan, killing Noah for mocking him.
“
Time for a little punk rock.
„
~ Duncan, blowing Owen up.
“
And then there was one. (Then he's in bed.) Right guys? (Finally notices he's alone and is annoyed.) Right. No one left to laugh at my excellent zingers. (Then he smiles and lays down on the bed while stabbing his knife in the side of his bed.) Good news is there's also no one left to reek up the trailer with jungle breath. Nobody to wake me up with screaming night terrors. (Sits up and mocking a scared person.) 'Mommy. Mommy.' (Lays back down with the smile.) And nobody with any chance at taking my guarantied million away.
„
~ Duncan, at first feeling annoyed at killing everyone on the show but then brushing it off and showing no remorse for what he's done.
“
Dear mom, how are you? I am in jail just because I killed some people. (Then is suddenly out of jail and smirking at the audience as the prison alarms go off and the dogs bark.) Well, it's been nice chatting with ya but I really got to run.
„
~ Duncan's last words before he runs away from prison and ends the video.
Trivia[]
Just like Mr. Krabs (Mr. Krabs' Unquenchable Blood Lust), he is a murderous parody of a cartoon character but unlike Mr. Krabs, Duncan doesn't die in the end and is at large. Also unlike Mr. Krabs, Duncan won at the end.
It is unknown how he quickly recovered from the rocks in the mattress.
It is also unknown how he killed the other campers that weren't seen dead.
It is also unknown how he escaped prison.
Courtney cheating on him with Alejandro is a reference to him cheating on her with Gwen, but the difference is many people would feel bad for him because he cared about her and he treated her right when they were together.
Despite his crimes, his victims were still jerks to him and has done nothing but mock him or didn't show sympathy towards him.
He is one of the most tragic versions of Duncan that only turned evil because of how he gets treated.
✓
